Find a local acupuncturist
To search by other criteria - name, town - click here
Latest posts are at the bottom of this page.
Use the filter buttons above to help find answers - click on the boxes
Q: Is there any evidence to support the use of acupuncture for the treatment of hereditary neuropathy with pressure palsy either as a preventative measure or during an episode?
A:If by evidence you mean appropriately conducted trials, the answer is no, at least as far as we know in the West. Research into acupuncture is not as commonplace as we would wish for a number of reasons, and when trials are conducted they tend to be for conditions where a substantial number of individuals can be gathered with exactly the same symptoms. HNPP is not very common. It is possible that there have been some research in China, but the vast majority of papers are not translated, and are often methodologically unacceptable in the west, working as they do from the assumption that acupuncture works and often more concerned with what works better, rather than checking whether it works.
That said, the two systems of medicine, conventional and Chinese, are based on entirely different conceptual bases, and the framework of Chinese medicine, based on the understanding of all phenomena as embodiments of energy (called 'qi'), can occasionally offer ways of interpreting and treating symptoms where conventional medicine has no answers. Advanced as Chinese understanding was in ancient times, it had none of the sophisticated interpretation of neurological disturbances which we have but looked at them through the framework of energy flow as a failure of local flow often predicated upon weaknesses in the flow of the whole system. Using needles to restore flow could help to reverse the deficiencies and blockages from which symptoms developed.
However, one has to be realistic with hereditary genetic conditions. Chinese medicine also has its concepts of genetic inheritance in the energy which is transmitted from parents to child in its creation, and while all energy is technically mutable, our experience is that inherited patterns are often quite difficult to treat and just as resistant to change as genetic conditions as understood in the West. Never say 'never', though. Our experience is equally that an although an imbalance may have been handed down from parent to child this does not that it becomes more greatly untreatable.
We would not want to generate false hope or expectation, though. As we said in an answer to a question about peripheral neuropathy:
Q: Is there any evidence that acupuncture can help with peripheral neuropathy?
A: There is some evidence that acupuncture may be helpful in the treatment of neuropathy, as our factsheet shows but this is not yet compelling enough for us make a firm recommendation. If you google for results from the US National Centre for Biotechnology Information, a very useful research resource, as 'ncbi acupuncture peripheral neuropathy' you will find references to a number of studies, some of which seem to show very positive results, others less so. Treating nerve damage with acupuncture, however, suffers from the same limitations as any other therapy. If the damage is already considerable there is less chance of reducing the pain and loss of sensation.
Chinese acupuncture is based on a theory of energy, called 'qi', and its flow and balance in the body. This can often mean that the needles used in conditions like peripheral neuropathy are often local to the problem and seen as a blockage in the flow of qi, but Chinese medicine has an elaborate understanding of the functional nature of the internal organs, understood entirely differently from in the West, and will often look at how the problem may also be a manifestation of a wider functional disturbance in the system. Then, of course, you have the underlying premise of the original Chinese medical systems which were largely asymptomatic, regarding the achevement of overall balance as the primary aim in the belief that this would deal with symptoms wherever they manifested.
The important element in treating peripheral neuropathy is understanding the physiological basis for its appearance in western terms and being realistic about what may be achieved. If this amounts to maintaining the status quo, or even as one very wise patient expressed it 'getting worse slower', then as long as this is the agreed basis for treatment, that is fine. Our members are trained to avoid raising unreal and unreasonable expectations in people with degenerative conditions or permanent physical damage. Talking to a BAcC member local to you face to face may be the best advice if you are considering treatment. They should be able to assess relatively quickly whether acupuncture was a worthwhile option for you.
This remains the best advice we can give you. A practitioner may see something in your state of balance which is a basis for treating the system as a whole with some expectation of change, however limited. The question may well be how much change and how sustainable. If it managed to quell the worst symptoms during an attack, which based on evidence for acupuncture and pain relief may be possible, then treatment may be very worthwhile.
Q: I have just had replacement shoulder surgery following a fall. I have lots of aches and pains in my lower arm, wrist and elbow. Would acupuncture help with the pain relief?
A: We often get enquiries in practice abotu problems such as yours. Any kind of fracture and subsequent surgical repair can lead to a number of aches and pains in the surrounding tissue and especially, as in your case, in muscles and tissues 'downstream' of the area of the injury.
We use the term 'downstream' advisedly. The theory of Chinese medicine is based on an understanding of the body as a system of energy, called 'qi', in movement through well-defined pathways. These are variously called channels or meridians, and as the names suggest, they need to be maintained and flowing for all the functions of the body to perform as they should. Where is a break, and especially where there has been surgery, there is always a chance that the flow has been disrupted, with consequent pain in the area and occasionally a disruption of organic function as the gradual weakening of the flow causes internal organs to under-perform.
This can especially be the case where there has been the formation of scar tissue, and treatment can often be quite simplistic, rather like 'joining the dots'. However, a practitioner will always be interested to see what makes one individual heal more quickly than another, and there may well be deeper underlying reasons in the whole system which have interfered with normal healing. This is one of the great strengths of Chinese medicine. In treating the person rather than the condition it can make sense of the great differences in people's rates of recovery by seeing the problems within the context of the overall pattern.
The one factor to take into account is that the shoulder is a very unstable joint. The ball and socket is not that well-defined in bone itself and the stability of the joint as a whole depends on layers of over-lapping muscles. Anything which disturbs the exact balance of these muscles can cause a large number of problems in the muscles which travel over the joint, rather like disturbing a cat's cradle in the childhood game. There may be a need for some form of massage to encourage the muscles to return to better function. Many members offer a form of Chinese massage, called tui na, alongside their acupuncture treatment, but most will know local massage therapists who may be able to help you if they feel that this is what you need.
Q: How do I find an acupuncturist who specialises in chronic pain (resulting from a car accident - spine and shoulder injuries). The only treatment offered are morphine based pain killers, which is not very appealing as it impedes ability to work and drive.
A:The important point to make is that from our perspective all of our members are equally well equipped to treat chronic pain. The nature of Chinese medicine is that it treats the person, not the condition, and although as in your case the problems do not arise from within the system itself, the ability to maximise your system's ability to heal itself would in our view be an important factor in your recovery. All of our members are trained to the same high standard, and there are oly a very few areas of work where we are beginning to recognise that there may be scope for postgraduate training to underpin expert practice, such as paediatrics or obstetrics.
As far as chronic pain is concerned, there is a substantial amount of evidence that acupuncture can be beneficial in providing pain relief. This rests largely on the fact that acupuncture became more popular in the West research into its effects focussed on pain relief because the outcome measures were relatively easy to assess, both the chemical ones such as neurotransmitters and also the patient assessment of their own levels of pain. We have produced a factsheet
which highlights some of this research, but while the experimental, i.e lab, results have been good, the more elaborate trials have been more equivocal. We believe that this owes a great deal to the trial designs, though; using formula treatments to achieve results is far removed from traditional practice.
However, as we said earlier, traditional acupuncture treats the person, not the condition, and this means that the best advice we can give you is to visit a BAcC member local to you to seek a brief face to face assessment of how they think treatment might be of benefit to you.
Our feeling about this is that acupuncture treatment will always bring you some relief from chronic pain. The only question is how much relief it provides and how sustainable the changes are. Although it might be positive boon to be pain free for a couple of days, if this is all that treatment can manage it is probably not financially sustainable, unless the patient has very deep pockets. BAcC members will always maintain a rolling review of chronic cases to ensure that their treatment remains focussed and that a treatment 'habit' doesn't lead people into expenditure beyond what they had intended or expected.
Q: GBS Guillian Barre syndrome - I have had two rounds of VIG treatment and again my weakness is increasing. Can accupuncture help me?
How do find an accupuncturist who would know about trating guillean barre syndrome? Is accupuncture treatment given under the NHS?
A:As you might imagine, we have been asked about many conditions already, and the last response we gave to a question about Guillain Barre syndrome was:
Q: I suffered with guillian barre syndrome, I have foot drop in my left foot and tight calves. Would acupuncture offer any relief?
A: Many of the symptoms which persist after an episode of Guillain Barre syndrome spontaneously remit within a year, so it is unusual and unfortunate to be troubled by residual effects.
There is not a great deal of research evidence of the treatment of Guillain Barre syndrome, although a group of Chinese researchers have posted a protocol for a review about to take place
which might produce a better picture once they have searched the databases for information.
To answer your question really means to look at what traditional Chinese acupuncture attempts to do, and that is to reinstate and maintain the flow of energy, 'qi' as it is called, in the body to ensure that everything functions as it should. Conditions like Guillain Barre which interfere with the normal flow in the muscles and tendons are seen in Chinese medical thought to be causes of blockage and deficiency, and at a very simplistic level the treatment is aimed at reinstating a blocked or missing flow. Of course, in practice things are a little more sophisticated than that, because the practitioner will want to know what happened to the system as a whole to let these particular symptoms appear where they did, and to decide whether it is really a local problem or one which requires a more subtle and systemic approach. Any condition involving a change in muscle tone or function may be benefited by acupuncture, though, and even the western medical acupuncture tradition sees this as a worthwhile intervention.
However, one important factor to bear in mind is that in a small percentage of cases residual symptoms not only persist for a great deal longer, but are sometimes intractable to treatment. If you did decide to give treatment a go and contacted a BAcC member local to you, it would be very important to establish very clear outcomes in order to assess whether the treatment is having an impact and a very clear sense of how many sessions to have before reviewing whether there has been progress and whether it is sustainable. It is in everyone's interests to ensure that, in Dr Johnson's famous words, continued treatment is not the triumph of hope over experience.
Our advice remains substantially the same. We have heard anecdotal evidence of successful treatment and also anecdotal evidence of prolonged treatment which has had no benefit at all. Chinese medicine works on an entirely different theoretical basis, however, and a western-named disease or condition could be diagnosed in many different ways. This will obviously have a direct bearing on how successful treatment may be. The best advice will always be to see a BAcC member local to you for a face to face assessment of what might be possible.
From our perspective, all of our practitioners are equally well qualified to treat all conditions. Chinese medicine treats the person, not the disease, and so there are relatively few areas where we recognise the importance of specialist training (paediatrics and obstetrics are two that we are researching). This means that you can be confident that anyone you identify near to you will be equipped to handle your problems.
As for getting acupuncture on the NHS, this is more of a problem. Most NHS personnel who offer acupuncture, generally doctors and physios, are limited to treating conditions for which there is good evidence and which fall within their scope of practice. You might just find that if you are offered physiotherapy that your practitioner mighy use acupuncture as a part of the package, but the chances are that they will not be using Chinese acupuncture, or at least, not Chinese acupuncture as we understand it. Many healthcare professionals now use Chinese points but often do so in a very formulaic cookbook way, and this will never be as effective as these points used within the framework of Chinese medicine itself.
A:There are very few research papers for the treatment of spondylitis with acupuncture, and those which have become available are generally Chinese studies which are both small and often methodologically flawed. A good example is this one:
This does not mean that it has no significance. The problem is that in the West there is more focus on the 'does it work?' question rather than, until recently in China, a focus on 'what works better?'. When you are using a two-thousand year old tradition which is embedded in the culture the use of the western drug testing model, the randomised double blind control trial, is not likely to be your model of choice. This latter test is not entirely appropriate for testing acupuncture, because reducing the variables to one is inconsistent with how good acupuncture is practised, so unsurprisingly the number of meaningful trials is limited.
That said, pain relief was one of the most heavily tested aspects of acupuncture treatment when it became more popular in the West, which is generally taken to be after Nixon's visit to China in the 1970s. The outcome measures for research purposes, the various neurotransmitters, and the patient reports of pain are easily measured, and many studies were done which showed that acupuncture does have an effect on the experience of pain. Our fact sheet on chronic pain
cites a number of the better known ones.
The main issue with using acupuncture for pain relief is weighing up the extent and sustainability of te relief against the cost of treatment, to put it bluntly. If, for example, treatment offers 48 hours of pain free life followed by a couple of days of bearable pain, then someone with deep pockets might find acupuncture treatment a reasonable investment. The vast majority of us, though, are not in this position, and also the greater majority of practitioners tend not to like to continue treatment indefinitely if there is no sign of a permanent reduction in the levels of pain.
The key aim with a condition like spondylitis is not a reversal of the fusing of vertebrae ultimately caused by the condition but a breaking of the cycle of inflammation which tends to sustain itself, i.e, inflamed areas press against surrounding tissue and further aggravate the inflammation. If treatment, whether by medication or acupuncture, can break this cycle there is a chance of maintaining a level of manageable pain.
The disease label covers a wide range of presentations, and you would need to see a BAcC member local to you for a brief face to face assessment of whether treatment would be worthwhile for you. From a Chinese medicine pesrspective there are also a number of systemic problems which can underpin what is in effect a local problem, and a practitioner will be able to assess quite rapidly what else may be going on in the system to inform the diagnosis in Chinese medicine terms and to give a clearer sense of the prognosis. He or she, if you do decide to have treatment, will be very clear about setting clear outcome measures to see whether the treatment is working, and regular review periods to assess whether treatment continues to be of benefit.